What If? app iconWhat If?

AI Text Adventure With Custom Actions: What If?

The problem with choosing from a menu

Most interactive stories give you a short list of options and call it freedom. You pick A or B, the story moves on, and a few pages later you realize every path leads to the same handful of endings. The author wrote the whole map before you arrived. You were only choosing which road to walk down.

That works fine for some readers. But if you've ever read a choice and thought, I'd rather do something else entirely, you know the frustration. The door is right there, and the story only lets you open it or walk past it. You wanted to knock first, or ask who lives there, or set the forest on fire.

This is the gap that custom actions are meant to fill.

The opposite problem: a blank page

The obvious fix is to let players type anything. Text adventures have worked this way for decades, and AI makes it more flexible than it used to be. You are no longer limited to a parser that only understands a few verbs.

But a blank text box has its own problem. Staring at an empty prompt asking what do you do? can be harder than it sounds. Sometimes you don't have an idea. Sometimes you just want the story to hand you a few interesting directions and let you pick one. A story that demands a brilliant input every single turn gets tiring fast.

So you end up with two imperfect options. One is a story that's easy to follow but too rigid. The other is a story that's wide open but asks a lot of you.

What custom actions actually change

The useful middle ground is simple: the story offers suggestions, and you can ignore them whenever you want.

When you have no idea what to do next, you pick from the options on screen and keep reading. When you have a better idea, you write it yourself and the story follows you there. You decide how much of the steering you want to do, and you can change your mind from one turn to the next.

This also changes how the story feels. When your own words shape the plot, it stops feeling like something you consume and starts feeling like something you're making. Two people can start from the same premise and end up in completely different places, because they made different calls at the first turning point.

How What If? handles it

What If? is an AI-powered interactive story app built around this idea. The setup is short:

  1. Choose your world. Start from a premise, such as stumbling on a mysterious door in the middle of a forest, being the last person on Earth, or getting the chance to rewrite history.
  2. Make your first move. Your opening choice sets the story in motion.
  3. Watch it unfold. The story is written in real time based on what you decide.

At every turning point, you get 4 possible paths. If one of them appeals to you, take it. If none do, create your own. That's the custom action part: you are never stuck with the options the story offered, so where it goes is up to you.

The story also doesn't end. There's no final page that forces you to close the book. You can keep following one thread or take a sharp turn, and it's easy to lose an evening to what if I'd done that instead?

The premium features are built around that habit of exploring:

  • Infinite unique stories across any genre you can imagine
  • Save and continue your stories whenever you like
  • Backtrack to explore the road not taken, so a choice you regret doesn't have to be permanent
  • Download a PDF of your story at any time

The backtracking is worth a note. In most branching stories, trying a different choice means starting over or flipping back through pages. Here you can return to an earlier point and take another path, which makes it easier to compare outcomes and see how much one decision changed.

A paperback print option is planned, but it isn't available yet. For now, the PDF is how you keep a copy of a story you've built.

Who this suits

If you like the structure of choose-your-own-adventure books but find the branches too narrow, this should feel more open. If you like free-form text adventures but find blank prompts tiring, the suggested paths give you somewhere to start. And if you enjoy asking odd hypotheticals and seeing where they go, the premise-first setup is built for that.

The stories are generated for you as you play, so what you read is one version that nobody else has. That's the point: the story only goes where your choices take it.

Closing

An AI text adventure with custom actions comes down to one thing: you decide how much control you want. Take the suggested path when you're curious, write your own when you have a better idea, and go back when you want to see what you missed. What If? is built around that loop. Pick a premise, make a move, and see where it leads.