What If?
How to Go Back and Change a Choice in a Story
You hit a fork in the story and pick the left path. Two pages later you wonder what the right path would have done. In most interactive stories, you can't find out without starting over.
That is the problem this article is about: wanting to go back and change a choice in a story, and finding that most formats won't let you do it cleanly.
Why choices usually feel permanent
Most interactive fiction is built around a fixed set of branches. An author wrote every path ahead of time, and the app or book moves you along one of them. Going back is awkward for a few reasons:
- The structure is hidden. You often can't see where the other branches are, so you don't know which choice to revisit.
- Progress is linear. Many apps only save your latest position, so a new choice means overwriting the old one.
- Replaying costs time. If a story has dozens of decisions, getting back to decision number 12 means making the first 11 again.
The result is that people either live with their choice or quit and start a new run, which breaks the thread that made the story feel like theirs.
The workarounds people use
If you have ever read a choose-your-own-adventure book, you know the finger-in-the-page trick. You hold your place at the fork, read ahead, and flip back if it goes badly. It works until you have three fingers in three places and the book is falling apart.
Digital versions have their own versions of this:
- Making manual save files before every big decision
- Restarting and replaying the early choices from memory
- Keeping notes on which option led where
- Looking up a walkthrough to avoid dead ends
All of these work, and all of them add friction. Some of them also drain the fun, because you're managing the story instead of reading it.
What you actually want when you go back
When someone says they want to change a choice, they usually want one of three things:
- To undo a mistake. You tapped the wrong option, or the story went somewhere you didn't mean it to.
- To satisfy curiosity. You liked the path you took, but you want to see the other one too.
- To compare outcomes. You want to see how a single decision changes everything after it.
The second and third are the interesting ones. They treat the story as something to explore, not a test with a right answer. A good tool for that makes going back cheap, so trying the other path doesn't cost you the first one.
How What If? handles it
What If? is an AI-powered interactive story app where the story is written as you play. You choose a world, such as a mysterious door in the middle of a forest, being the last person on Earth, or a chance to rewrite history. Then you make your first move and the story starts.
At every turning point, you get four possible paths. If none of them appeal to you, you can write your own, so you aren't limited to the options on the screen. Because the story is generated as you go, it isn't a set of branches someone drew in advance. It is a story that only exists because of the choices you made.
For going back, the relevant premium features are these:
- Backtrack and explore the road not taken. You can return to an earlier point and take a different path, which is the thing most interactive stories make difficult.
- Save and continue anytime. You can put a story down and pick it up later, so a different path doesn't have to be explored in one sitting.
- Download a PDF of your story. You can keep a copy of a story you've read at any time.
The story also never ends. There is no final page, so it is easy to fall down a rabbit hole of "what if" paths. Going back to try a different choice is part of how the app is meant to be used.
The premium plan also includes infinite unique stories across any genre you can imagine. If you want to try a different choice in a story, or start a different story altogether, you aren't running out of material.
A paperback print option is planned but is not available yet.
A few tips for exploring alternate paths
Whether you use What If? or another tool, these habits make going back more rewarding:
- Note the turning points. The decisions that feel small at the time are often the ones that change the most.
- Change one thing at a time. If you swap several choices at once, you can't tell which one mattered.
- Try the option you would never pick. The least likely path is often the most surprising.
- Write your own option. If the four suggested paths don't fit, say what you actually want to do.
Closing
Wanting to go back and change a choice in a story is not a sign that you made the wrong one. It's curiosity about what else could have happened. Most formats treat that curiosity as a problem to work around. What If? treats it as part of the story, with backtracking, saving, and a story that keeps going wherever you take it.