What If?
Stories Where Readers Choose What Happens
You are halfway through a story when a character opens the door you would have left closed. Or she trusts the wrong person. Or the plot turns left and you were hoping it would turn right. You can keep reading, but you can't change anything. The story was finished before you got there.
That is the gap that stories where readers choose what happens try to fill. Here is how these stories work, where older versions run out, and what to look for in one.
The problem with a story that is already written
A traditional book is a fixed path. The author made every decision, and your job is to follow along. That is the point of a novel, and plenty of people love it for exactly that reason.
But some readers want to take part. They finish a chapter and think, what if she had gone through the door? In a printed book, that question has nowhere to go. You can imagine your own answer, but the page won't write it for you.
What branching stories got right, and where they stop
Choose-your-own-adventure books were an early answer. At the end of a section you pick an option, jump to a numbered page, and keep reading. Many of us grew up with them, and the format still works well for a quick, playful read.
The limits show up quickly, though:
- The author wrote every branch ahead of time. Once you have read enough of the book, you have seen most of what it can do.
- You can only choose from what is offered. If none of the options match what you want to try, you pick the closest one and move on.
- The story ends. After a handful of decisions, you reach an ending, and then you go back and try again.
Video games with dialogue trees have a similar shape. They feel more flexible, but the paths are still written in advance by someone else.
What makes a choice feel like yours
If you want a story that responds to you, a few things matter more than the rest:
- Choices that change what comes next. A decision should shape the story from that point on, not just flavor one paragraph.
- The freedom to go off-script. Sometimes the options on offer are not the ones you want. Being able to write your own is what separates a menu from a story you are steering.
- No forced finish line. If you are enjoying a thread, it should be able to keep going.
- A way back. Curiosity is half the fun. Being able to return to a decision and try the other road lets you explore without losing your place.
Those are the things What If? was built around.
How What If? handles it
What If? is an AI-powered interactive story app. Every story is written in real time as you play, so the version you read is one nobody else has seen.
Here is how it works:
- Choose your world. You start from a premise, such as stumbling on a mysterious door in the middle of a forest, being the last person on Earth, or getting the chance to rewrite history.
- Make your first move. Your opening decision sets the story in motion.
- Watch it unfold. At each turning point, you get four possible paths.
- Or write your own. If none of the four suit you, you can create your own path instead. Where the story goes is up to you.
The story never ends on its own. There is no last page that closes the book, which makes it easy to fall down a rabbit hole of "what if" paths, one decision leading to another.
Premium features
The premium version adds a few things that matter if you want to spend real time with a story:
- Infinite unique stories across any genre you can imagine.
- Save and continue your stories whenever you like, so you can pick one up again later.
- Backtrack to explore the road not taken, which is the closest thing to answering the original what if she had gone through the door? question.
- PDF download of your story at any time, so you can keep what you have written.
A paperback printing option is coming soon, but it is not available yet.
Who this is for
What If? suits readers who like to wonder about the other option. If you were the kid who kept a finger in the previous page of a gamebook so you could undo a bad choice, this is that habit with the walls taken down. The paths aren't limited to what an author scripted, and you aren't limited to the options on screen.
It is probably not for someone who wants a carefully crafted, single authored narrative from start to finish. For that, a good novel is still the right tool.
The short version
Stories where readers choose what happens have been around for a long time, but most of them hand you a fixed map. What If? gives you four paths at every turn, lets you write your own when none fit, and keeps the story going for as long as you want to follow it. Pick a starting point, make your first move, and see where it goes.